







The guide in 60 seconds
Mechanism
A passive ETF tracks an index and copies its composition. An active ETF has a manager who picks the securities to try to beat an index or to move away from it. Both trade continuously on an exchange.
Costs
The annual fee (TER) is the most visible one. The bid-ask spread, broker commissions and currency conversion come on top. A gap of 1 point a year removes about 17% of the final capital over 20 years (assumption: 7% gross, no contributions).
Results
Neither approach wins for certain. The active fund first has to recover its higher fees, then beat them, and keep doing so over time.
Risks
Both lose value when the market falls. The active ETF adds manager risk and sometimes concentration. The passive ETF follows the index down all the way.
Horizon
The longer the horizon, the more the fees compound. Over 5 years the gap is barely visible. Over 30 years it weighs more than many product choices.
To check before buying
The TER in the KID, the reference index, the replication method, the fund size, the bid-ask spread and the trading currency.
| Criterion | Passive ETF | Active ETF |
|---|---|---|
| Objective | Track an index | Pick securities, often relative to an index |
| Ongoing charges | 0.12% to 0.20% on three funds tracking major indices | Higher in general (0.25% on three JPMorgan funds) |
| Gap with the index | Small, measured by tracking difference | Intended, measured by tracking error |
| Transparency | Published index, known composition | Published holdings, manager choices not known in advance |
| Specific risk | Market risk, replication risk | Market risk, manager risk, style risk |
| Outperformance | Not sought | Sought, never guaranteed |
| Typical use | Core of a portfolio | Targeted add-on, or a core chosen knowingly |
To compare costs with numbers, go straight to the seven simulators. For the criterion-by-criterion detail, see the comparison table. To buy, the platforms are in the platform comparison.
The five-minute summary
- An ETF is an exchange-traded fund. The words "passive" and "active" describe how the securities are chosen, not how sound the product is.
- Fees are certain, outperformance is not. An active fund that costs 1.2% a year must gain 1 point more than the passive equivalent at 0.2% just to break even.
- Public studies mostly compare traditional active funds with indices. For now they do not say the same about active ETFs, a recent category in Europe.
- Holding costs (TER) are not buying costs: spread, brokerage and currency conversion are paid on top.
- Combining both is possible: a broad passive core and one or two active satellites. The combination is not better in principle; it answers a question about risk and cost.
- This guide recommends no product. It gives the method to judge an ETF yourself, and seven simulators to put numbers on the effect of fees.
What is an ETF?
An ETF (exchange-traded fund) is an investment fund listed on an exchange. You buy and sell it like a share, at a price that moves continuously during market hours. Behind it, the fund holds a basket of securities: shares, bonds, sometimes commodities or derivatives.
In Europe, the large majority of ETFs sold to retail investors are UCITS funds. This directive sets rules on diversification, liquidity and transparency. It applies to a fund whatever its management style: a passive ETF and an active ETF fall under the same framework.
The creation and redemption mechanism explains why the exchange price stays close to the value of the securities held. Market makers, which are authorised financial institutions, buy or sell ETF shares continuously. When the price drifts from the value of the basket, they arbitrage: they create or redeem shares with the issuer and bring the price back towards the value. The mechanism is not perfect. It weakens when the underlying market is closed or under stress.
Definition
Net asset value (NAV): the value of one share, calculated from the price of the securities held. The ETF's exchange price can differ slightly from it: you pay the exchange price, not the NAV.
Two notions come back throughout this guide. Management describes how securities are chosen: follow an index (passive) or decide (active). Structure describes the wrapper: listed ETF, traditional UCITS fund, alternative fund. Confusing the two is the most frequent mistake. An ETF can be active, and an unlisted fund can be passive.
An active ETF is therefore not an "ETF that beats the market". It is an ETF whose manager has room to decide the composition of the portfolio. That room can be narrow: some active funds stay very close to their index. It can also be wide.
Passive management: tracking an index
A passive ETF seeks to reproduce the performance of an index such as MSCI World, S&P 500 or MSCI Europe. The index is a list of securities with weighting rules published by a provider. The fund does not decide what to buy: it applies the rule.
There are two replication methods:
- Physical replication: the fund holds the securities of the index, or a representative sample. The iShares Core MSCI World holds about 1,250 lines according to its October 2026 factsheet, because the fund uses a so-called "optimised" method (sampling): it does not necessarily hold every security in the index.
- Synthetic replication: the fund holds a basket of securities and enters a swap contract with a bank, which pays it the performance of the index. This method adds counterparty risk, which is regulated. It makes it possible to track indices that are hard to access.
Tracking is never perfect. Two measures describe it, and they are often confused:
- tracking difference: the performance gap between the fund and the index over a period. It comes mainly from fees, partly offset by securities lending income when the fund lends;
- tracking error: the variability of that gap from one day to the next. It measures how regular the tracking is, not its level.
Why the distinction matters: a fund can have a tracking difference of −0.2% a year, close to its TER, and an almost nil tracking error. That is the typical case of a good ETF on a major index. A fund can also show a small tracking difference one year by chance and a very variable one the next: look at several years.
An index is not "the market". It is a construction rule chosen by a provider. It sets the number of securities, whether weights follow market capitalisation or something else, and how often the index is rebalanced. Choosing a passive ETF is therefore already a choice: the choice of the index.
Example taken from the source
The October 2026 factsheet of the iShares Core MSCI World UCITS ETF (USD, accumulating, ISIN IE00B4L5Y983) shows a TER of 0.20%, an Irish domicile, an "optimised" methodology, a physical structure and the MSCI World Net reference index. The share class's net assets exceed USD 146 billion. Source: iShares factsheet of October 2026, consulted on 17 November 2026.
Active management: choosing the securities
An active manager decides which securities to buy, in what quantity and when. The objective is to do better than a reference index, or to offer a different risk profile. The fund publishes this reference index, which serves as a yardstick. It is not always a binding constraint.
The room for manoeuvre varies a lot:
- enhanced indexing stays close to the index, with small overweights and underweights. The three JPMorgan funds noted for this guide describe themselves in this category: their objective is a return above the MSCI World, MSCI Europe or MSCI ACWI, by investing actively;
- concentrated management holds few securities, with strong convictions;
- quantitative approaches apply numerical rules to criteria such as valuation or earnings quality, without a standard index defining them;
- thematic or sector funds pick a theme, with or without an index rule.
The word "active" says nothing about the level of active risk. For an enhanced index fund, the targeted tracking error is low. For a concentrated fund, it is high.
Key point
An active ETF is not a "smarter" ETF. It offers a chance to move away from the index, in both directions, and it charges for it. The question is not whether active management can win, but how many funds manage it, for how long, after fees.
Active and passive ETFs: the table of differences
The table below uses fifteen criteria. The cells describe the general tendency of a category, not a particular product: a given fund can differ, so always check its KID and prospectus.
| Criterion | Passive ETF | Active ETF |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Objective | Reproduce an index | Beat an index or aim for a risk profile |
| 2. Management decision | Index rules | Manager's decision within the prospectus |
| 3. Reference index | Replication target | Yardstick, not always a constraint |
| 4. Ongoing charges | Generally lower | Generally higher |
| 5. Portfolio turnover | Low, tied to index changes | Variable, sometimes high |
| 6. Internal transaction costs | Often low | Higher if turnover is high |
| 7. Gap with the index | Almost nil, measured by tracking difference | Intended, positive or negative |
| 8. Transparency of holdings | Published index | Holdings published at a frequency set by the issuer |
| 9. Manager risk | Almost nil | Present |
| 10. Concentration risk | That of the index | That of the index, plus that of the manager's choices |
| 11. Counterparty risk | Only with synthetic replication or securities lending | Only with derivatives or securities lending |
| 12. Predictability of the relative result | High | Low |
| 13. Liquidity on the exchange | Good on large funds | Variable, often lower for recent funds |
| 14. Size and age | Several very large and old funds | More recent category in Europe, funds often smaller |
| 15. Closure risk | Lower on large funds | Higher on small funds |
Point 4 is the simplest to check. Point 7 is the most misunderstood: a passive ETF can lose to its index because of its fees, and an active ETF can win or lose. Neither is guaranteed to track or beat anything.
Active ETFs and traditional active funds
Performance studies of active management mostly cover traditional active funds: unlisted UCITS funds sold by banks, insurers and distribution networks. An active ETF is an active fund that is listed, often with a lighter fee structure. The two are not the same thing.
| Criterion | Traditional active fund | Active ETF |
|---|---|---|
| Listing | Unlisted, subscription at the net asset value | Listed, bought and sold continuously on an exchange |
| Price paid | Net asset value of the day | Exchange price, with a bid-ask spread |
| Sales channels | Bank networks, life insurance, brokers | Stock brokers |
| Fees | Often higher, entry fees possible | Often lower, no entry fee charged by the fund |
| History available | Long | Short |
| Performance studies | Many | Few, recent category |
Reading trap
A statistic such as "x% of active funds do worse than their index" concerns the category studied, usually traditional active funds. It does not hold for a given active ETF. The two do not share the same fees, size or length of observation.
Costs: TER, spread, brokerage, currency, tracking difference
The cost of an ETF is paid in several places. Confusing them leads to poor comparisons.
| Cost | Who charges it | When | Where to read it |
|---|---|---|---|
| TER or ongoing charges | The issuer, inside the value of the fund | Continuously, every day, with no invoice line | KID, fund factsheet |
| Fund transaction costs | The fund's internal purchases and sales | Continuously, inside the performance | KID ("transaction costs" line) |
| Bid-ask spread | The market maker | At every purchase and every sale | Order book |
| Brokerage | Your broker | At every order | Broker's fee schedule |
| Currency conversion | Your broker, sometimes the fund | If the fund's or listing currency differs from yours | Broker's fee schedule |
| Custody fees | Your broker | Annual, depending on the broker | Broker's fee schedule |
| Taxes | The State | On sale or on income, depending on the wrapper | Our tax guides, for example the French one |
Two concrete readings help to place the orders of magnitude. The iShares Core MSCI World factsheet shows a TER of 0.20%. The KID of the Vanguard FTSE All-World (USD, accumulating) gives 0.14% of ongoing charges and 0.02% of transaction costs, so 0.16% in total in the issuer's cost table, and an annual impact rounded to 0.2%. Source: Vanguard documents consulted on 17 November 2026, data as of 31 October 2026 for the factsheet and end of 2025 for the KID.
Securities lending, a cost that can become income
Some physical ETFs lend part of their securities to intermediaries for a fee. For the iShares fund cited above, the KID states that the fund receives 62.5% of the lending income and BlackRock receives 37.5% as lending agent. The income reduces the tracking difference. It adds counterparty risk, which is covered by collateral. Check the lending policy of each fund in its prospectus.
Tracking difference, the real cost of a passive ETF
The TER announces a cost. The tracking difference measures what you actually lost against the index over a given period. For a passive ETF, compare the two: a fund with a 0.20% TER and a tracking difference of −0.18% has tracked well, while a fund with a 0.10% TER and a difference of −0.50% has a hidden problem.
For an active ETF, tracking difference does not mean the same thing: the gap with the index is intended. Look instead at net performance against the index over several cycles, and at how regular it is.
Do active ETFs do better than passive ETFs?
It depends on the fund, the period and the way of measuring, and no public study can name a winning family with certainty. What can be established is limited.
Gross, net, relative, risk-adjusted
Four ways of measuring performance give four different answers:
- gross performance is before fees. It is the manager's, not yours;
- net performance is after the fund's ongoing charges. It is the one that matters to the saver;
- relative performance compares the fund with an index or an equivalent fund. It depends on the choice of yardstick: a global fund compared with a European index tells you nothing;
- risk-adjusted performance relates the return to volatility, for example with the Sharpe ratio. A fund that beats the index by taking more risk has not necessarily managed better.
What public studies say, and their limits
Three sources serve as references to compare active and passive management in Europe:
- the SPIVA Europe scorecard from S&P Dow Jones Indices compares active funds with their benchmark by category. Its method weights funds equally, keeps closed funds in the calculation and measures fund returns net of fees. It covers active funds, not active ETFs;
- the Morningstar Active/Passive Barometer measures the share of active funds that survive and beat a composite of comparable passive funds, net of fees. It does not separate active ETFs in its conclusions;
- the ESMA report on costs and performance of retail investment products, published every year, compares costs and returns across products, including active and passive management. The detailed figures of the 2025 edition could not be read in full for this guide: they are marked "not verified" in the sources section.
These studies agree on three points that you can keep without putting numbers on them:
- a majority of active funds do not do better than their index over ten or fifteen years, after fees, in most of the categories studied;
- the share of active funds that beat the index varies a lot with the category, the period and the region: it is not fixed;
- a fund that beats the index in one year is unlikely to do so systematically in the following years: persistence is weak.
Figures deliberately left out
The exact percentages change every half-year and every category. We do not reproduce them in the text, so as not to freeze a figure that will be wrong in six months. Open the report at the source and check the date of its latest edition. The links are in the section "Sources, data and methodology".
Survivorship bias
A fund that performs badly is often closed or merged into another. It disappears from the rankings. If you look only at funds that are still open, the average performance of the category looks better than it was. A serious study keeps closed funds in the calculation, which the SPIVA method does. A ranking taken from a brokerage website, which shows only current funds, suffers from this bias.
What this says about active ETFs
Almost nothing definitive. The category is recent in Europe, the funds are often small and young, and the history is short. A performance over two or three years does not separate talent from luck. To judge an active ETF, look at the fees, the method, the announced tracking error, the size of the fund and how regular its gap with the index is, not at a single return figure.
Compounded fees: why 1 point of fees weighs so much
Fees are taken from the value of the fund every year. What they remove in one year no longer works in the following years: it is a compounding effect, like interest, but in reverse.
An example with explicit assumptions. You invest €10,000 once, with no later contributions. The market returns 7% a year before fees, at a constant rate. A passive ETF costs 0.2% a year and an active ETF 1.2%. The active ETF does neither better nor worse than the market before fees.
| Duration | No fees | Passive at 0.2% | Active at 1.2% | Gap | Gap as % of passive |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 5 years | €14,026 | €13,895 | €13,256 | €638 | 4.6% |
| 10 years | €19,672 | €19,307 | €17,573 | €1,733 | 9.0% |
| 20 years | €38,697 | €37,276 | €30,883 | €6,393 | 17.2% |
| 30 years | €76,123 | €71,968 | €54,271 | €17,696 | 24.6% |
Reading: over 30 years, a 1-point annual fee gap removes about a quarter of the final capital that the low-cost fund would give. The mechanism is unsurprising: you pay a percentage on a value that grows. The larger the capital, the more the same percentage costs in euros.
This table does not prove that active is worse. It shows what the active fund has to recover. If the manager adds 1 point a year before fees (8% instead of 7%), the active ETF at 1.2% gets exactly the result of the passive ETF at 0.2%. It therefore has to beat its index by about 1 point a year, gross, over the whole period, just to equal the passive fund. The second simulator calculates this threshold for your fees.
30-year case, €10,000 at 7% gross
Final capital by level of annual fees: 0.1% gives €74,017, 0.2% gives €71,968, 0.5% gives €66,144, 1% gives €57,435, 1.5% gives €49,840, 2% gives €43,219. Each extra half-point costs about a tenth of the final capital. Simulation without tax, constant gross return, a working assumption and not a forecast.
The risks of an ETF, active or passive
An ETF is not "risk-free" because it is diversified or listed. Ten risks are worth knowing.
| Risk | What it means | Passive | Active |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market | The value falls when markets fall | Yes, fully | Yes, with a cushion or an amplification depending on the manager |
| Specific | A company or a sector collapses | Diluted by diversification | Diluted less if the portfolio is concentrated |
| Concentration | A few securities weigh heavily | That of the index (large US stocks weigh heavily in world indices) | That of the index, plus the manager's bets |
| Currency | The currency of the assets moves against yours | Yes, except the hedged part | Yes, except the hedged part |
| Liquidity | Difficulty selling at the price you want | Low on large funds | Higher on small funds |
| Counterparty | A bank does not honour its commitments | Swap, securities lending | Derivatives, securities lending |
| Derivatives | Leveraged or hedging instruments | Synthetic replication | Depending on the strategy |
| Tracking | The fund moves away from its index | Yes, limited | Intended, hence a risk of its own |
| Manager | The manager's choices turn out badly | No | Yes |
| Closure | The fund is liquidated and you are repaid at the value of the day | Rare on large funds | More frequent on small funds |
Closure risk surprises people: when an ETF is liquidated, holders are repaid at the net asset value. You do not lose your capital because of the closure. You do have to reinvest elsewhere, at a time that is not of your choosing, and an unrealised gain is then taxed according to your wrapper.
Risk indicators: volatility, maximum drawdown, correlation, beta, Sharpe
- Volatility is the average size of the moves around the mean, as an annual percentage. It does not say whether a move is up or down.
- Maximum drawdown is the largest loss between a peak and the trough that follows. It is the figure that speaks to someone who has to hold on through the fall.
- Correlation measures whether two investments move together: from 1 (together) to −1 (in opposite directions). It often rises in a crisis.
- Beta measures a fund's sensitivity to its market. A beta of 1.00, like the one the iShares factsheet gives over 3 years, means the fund moved like the index.
- The Sharpe ratio relates the return above the risk-free rate to volatility. The higher it is, the better the risk was paid. It is calculated over a period and is useful by comparison.
An active ETF is also judged by its tracking error, its information ratio and its maximum drawdown relative to the index. A fund that beats the index by 1 point with 6 points of tracking error has a low information ratio: the gain is thin for the risk taken.
Smart beta, alternative indices and quantitative management
Between pure passive and discretionary active, there is a grey zone. A "smart beta" ETF tracks an index, so it is passive in the sense of tracking, but the index rests on a rule other than market capitalisation: equal weighting, low volatility, value, quality, dividends. The fund has no manager who decides; the index rule does.
| Criterion | Market-cap weighted index | Alternative index (smart beta) | Active management |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who decides | The index rule | The index rule, with a chosen bias | The manager |
| Rule published | Yes | Yes | Not always in detail |
| Gap with the market | Nil by construction | Large, but systematic | Variable |
| Ongoing charges | Low | Intermediate | Higher |
| Specific risk | Market, concentration | Market, style risk that can last for years | Market, manager |
A style bias that pays off over one period does not always pay off over the next. A "value" fund can underperform the market for ten years. Buying a smart beta fund is a bet on a style: holding it through the bad years requires having understood it beforehand.
Equity ETFs and bond ETFs: active and passive do not weigh the same
Equity markets for large companies are very liquid and closely followed. Prices absorb public information quickly, which leaves little room for a manager to find a lasting edge. Bond markets are more fragmented: a bond trades over the counter, and an issuer often has several series. Replicating a bond index is more costly and more approximate, which changes the comparison.
- On equity ETFs, the TER is the first visible cost item, and the tracking difference of a good fund is close to the TER.
- On bond ETFs, the cost of replication weighs more: sampling is the rule, tracking errors are wider and spreads are sometimes high.
- On money market ETFs, the fee difference accounts for almost all of the return, since the gross return is low.
The reasoning of this guide holds for bonds: fees come out of a lower return, so the relative effect is stronger. The simulators let you enter a gross return of 2% or 3% and see it for yourself.
The European market for active ETFs
Active ETFs arrived late in Europe compared with the United States. The UCITS framework allows a listed fund to be managed actively, provided it follows the rules on transparency and diversification. The European regulator (ESMA) set out, in its Q&A on the application of the UCITS directive, how a fund must state in its documents whether it is actively or passively managed, and its relationship to its reference index. The terms used for the fund must be consistent across the prospectus, the KID and marketing communications.
Two reservations apply to statistics on this category:
- the number of funds and the assets under management change quickly. Figures published by issuers and data providers carry observation dates, which differ from their publication date. A figure published in November is often struck in September or June;
- definitions vary: some counts include "enhanced index" ETFs as active, others classify them as passive. Two sources can therefore give two totals for the same month.
We give neither a number of funds nor total assets for the category: we could not verify them against a dated primary source. See the "not verified" list at the end of the guide.
Sheets of six UCITS ETFs taken from the source
The six sheets below were taken from issuer documents. They illustrate the method; they are not a selection: they are neither recommended, nor ranked, nor representative of their category. No overall score is given. The data change: always check the KID and the factsheet in force on the day of your purchase.
| Fund | ISIN | Management | Reference index | Annual fees recorded | Domicile, currency, income | Date of the data |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| iShares Core MSCI World UCITS ETF | IE00B4L5Y983 | Passive, "optimised" physical replication | MSCI World Net | TER 0.20% | Ireland, USD, accumulating | Factsheet of October 2026 |
| Vanguard FTSE All-World UCITS ETF | IE00BK5BQT80 | Passive, physical replication | FTSE All-World | Ongoing charges 0.14% | Ireland, USD, accumulating | Factsheet as of 31 October 2026 |
| Amundi Core MSCI Europe UCITS ETF (class A) | LU1437015735 | Passive (replication method not recorded) | MSCI Europe | Management fees and other costs 0.12% | Luxembourg (SICAV); currency and income treatment of class A not recorded | Factsheet as of 31 July 2026 |
| JPM Global Research Enhanced Index Equity Active UCITS ETF | IE00BF4G6Y48 | Active, enhanced index | MSCI World Net | TER 0.25% | Ireland, USD, accumulating | Factsheet showing 31 August 2026 |
| JPM Europe Research Enhanced Index Equity Active UCITS ETF | IE00BF4G7183 | Active, enhanced index | MSCI Europe Net | TER 0.25% | Ireland, EUR, accumulating | Factsheet showing 31 August 2026 |
| JPM All Country Research Enhanced Index Equity Active UCITS ETF | Not recorded | Active, enhanced index | MSCI ACWI | TER 0.25% | Ireland, USD, accumulating according to the factsheet | Factsheet showing 31 August 2026 |
Three remarks on this table:
- the Vanguard FTSE All-World saw its ongoing charges fall: an issuer document shows 0.19% before a reduction announced to holders on 21 July 2026 and effective on 28 July 2026, and the October 2026 factsheet shows 0.14%. A figure seen on a third-party site may therefore be the old one;
- the three JPMorgan funds are described by their manager as active but close to their index, with a TER of 0.25%. They represent the "enhanced index" part of the active ETF market: their gap with the index is deliberately contained. They do not sum up all active ETFs;
- the dates of the JPMorgan factsheets are those the document displays. The page where we took these data is more than a year old in the search tool: re-read the figures on the issuer's website before any decision. See the "not verified" list.
Reading a factsheet, an example
A TER of 0.25% for an active enhanced index fund against 0.20% for a global passive fund gives a gap of 0.05 points a year: the manager has to add 0.05 points a year before fees to equal the passive fund, which the second simulator confirms. The fee gap is small here. The question becomes: what tracking error is acceptable, and for how many years?
Comparing ETFs on the same market
Comparing an active ETF on European equities with a passive ETF on US equities makes no sense. To compare two funds, four conditions apply:
- the same universe: MSCI World against MSCI World, or a comparable region;
- the same reference currency: a dollar share class and a euro share class cannot be compared without taking currency into account;
- the same treatment of income: accumulating against accumulating, distributing against distributing;
- the same period, preferably several years and a full cycle, using the net performance published in the KID.
When one of the four is missing, the comparison is wrong, whatever the result. In table 8, the two most comparable funds are the iShares Core MSCI World (passive, 0.20%) and the JPM Global Research Enhanced Index Equity Active (active, 0.25%): same MSCI World universe, same share class currency, same accumulated income. We do not publish their past performance in this guide: we could not re-read it in the KID in force on the date of the guide. Go and read it in the two documents, over the same period.
How to assess an active ETF
An active ETF is judged on ten points. None is enough on its own, and the last counts as much as the first.
| Point | Question to ask | Where to find it |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Strategy | Does the fund say clearly how it picks its securities? | Prospectus, investment policy |
| 2. Reference index | What is it, and does the fund compare itself with it or track it? | KID, factsheet |
| 3. Ongoing charges | What is the TER, and what does it include? | KID |
| 4. Transaction costs | Is portfolio turnover high? | KID, annual report |
| 5. Targeted tracking error | How far can the fund move away from the index? | Prospectus, factsheet |
| 6. Team and process | Who manages it, since when, with what method? | Issuer's website |
| 7. Size and age | Has the fund lived through a market fall? How large is it? | Factsheet, history |
| 8. Liquidity | What is the bid-ask spread, at the time I plan to buy? | Your broker's order book |
| 9. Composition | What concentration, which countries, which sectors? | Factsheet, top holdings |
| 10. Closure risk | Is the fund large enough for the issuer to keep it? | Assets under management on the factsheet |
An active ETF that does not pass half of these points is a bet you do not need to make. The strategy must be writable in one sentence that you understand: if it escapes you, you will not know why the fund underperformed either.
How to assess a passive ETF
- The index. What does it contain, with what weighting? An "MSCI World" does not contain emerging countries. A "global market" index may. The name is not enough.
- The fees. TER, and the KID's transaction costs. With the same index, compare.
- The replication. Full physical, sampled physical or synthetic? In the last two cases, read what the prospectus says about counterparty risk.
- The tracking difference. Over three to five years, is it close to the TER? The KID or the factsheet gives it.
- The size. A fund of a few tens of millions of euros can close. Large funds are insurance against that decision.
- The currency. Index currency, share class currency, listing currency. All three can differ.
- Accumulating or distributing. Depending on your wrapper, one is simpler. See our tax guides, for example the French one.
- The bid-ask spread. Measured during the hours when you buy, not at the open.
Active and passive ETFs in a long-term portfolio
This chapter describes generic structures for teaching purposes. It is addressed to nobody in particular and does not replace personalised advice: a portfolio is built from a horizon, a tolerance for losses and a tax situation that we do not know.
| Structure | Principle | Active share | Advantage | Limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All passive | One to three broad ETFs | 0% | Low costs, simplicity | No chance of moving away from the index, in either direction |
| Core-satellite | A passive core, active or thematic satellites | Often 10% to 30% | Bets stay bounded | Satellites pile up quickly, and so do their fees |
| Active core | Broad active funds as the base | Majority | Can move away from the concentration of an index | Higher fees, manager risk on most of the portfolio |
| By asset class | Equities, bonds, money market, each in passive or active | Variable | Active only where it can make sense, for example bonds | Requires regular rebalancing decisions |
The "10% to 30%" share given for core-satellite is a common order of magnitude in educational literature, not a rule. Choosing this share is a personal decision. A satellite is justified by a precise reason: a theme you understand, an area the core covers poorly, a different horizon.
Regular or lump-sum investing
Investing a sum every month (dollar-cost averaging, DCA) smooths the purchase price: you buy more shares when the price falls and fewer when it rises. Regular investing does not systematically beat investing in one go. If the market rises on average, investing straight away does better in a majority of cases: the money is exposed for longer. Regular contributions reduce regret and the risk of entering just before a fall, not market risk.
For most savers, the question does not arise: you invest your savings at the pace they arrive. When you have a large sum at once (inheritance, sale), the choice between a single entry and spreading over a few months is a decision about comfort and tolerance for regret, not a decision about guaranteed performance.
One technical point does weigh in practice: a broker's fixed fees. A €1 commission on a €100 order costs 1%, on €1,000 it costs 0.1%. For small contributions, group your purchases or use a low-cost savings plan where one exists. The third and the seventh simulator put numbers on the effect of contributions and order fees.
What taxes apply to ETFs in France?
This section describes the general framework for a French tax resident. It does not replace reading the full French tax guide, which details the forms, nor consulting the tax administration. If you live in another country, the rules differ: see the national tax guides of this site. No tax reviewer is named on this page: the rules below are taken from the official pages read for the tax guide, and points not re-read are flagged.
| Wrapper | Principle | Status in this guide |
|---|---|---|
| Ordinary securities account | Capital gain on sale and distributed income: flat tax (PFU) of 31.4% on 2026 income (12.8% income tax and 18.6% social levies), or the option for the progressive scale. An accumulating ETF produces no tax return line as long as it is not sold. A switch counts as a sale. | Taken from the site's tax guide, source impots.gouv.fr and economie.gouv.fr |
| PEA (French equity savings plan) | Fund eligibility conditions, ceilings, exit regime depending on age of the plan | Not verified in this guide: see the official source before acting |
| Life insurance in unit-linked contracts | Only some ETFs are offered, tax specific to the contract | Not verified in this guide |
| Other EU countries | Different regimes, covered by the site's national guides | See the tax guide for your country |
What this page does not put numbers on
The simulators include no tax by default. Tax depends on your wrapper, your situation and the date of sale, and it applies in the same way to an active fund and a passive fund in the same wrapper. It therefore does not change the ranking of fees. It reduces the final result of both. The seventh simulator lets you add a simple tax rate, isolated and explained.
Fifteen investor mistakes to avoid
Believing an ETF is safe because it is diversified.
A world equity ETF falls when equities fall. Diversification reduces the risk of one company, not that of the market.
Choosing an ETF on last year's performance.
An annual ranking mostly measures luck and the style of the moment. Over several years, fees, strategy and regularity count more.
Comparing a fund net of fees with a gross index.
An index has no fees, a fund does. Compare the fund with another fund, or look at the tracking difference.
Looking only at the TER.
Spread, brokerage and currency conversion are paid on top and can exceed the TER for someone who often buys small amounts.
Confusing an active ETF with a traditional active fund.
Performance studies mostly concern the latter. They do not transfer automatically to the former.
Thinking an active fund protects you in a fall.
Some cushion it, others amplify it. Look at its past maximum drawdown, not the brochure's promise.
Buying a tiny fund.
A small fund has more closure risk and a wider spread. Assets under management are on the factsheet.
Ignoring the currency.
A dollar fund listed in euros remains exposed to the dollar. Currency works both ways, including on a "Europe" ETF whose assets are in other currencies.
Buying at the open or at the close.
Spreads are often wider at the ends of the session. Place the order when the underlying markets are open.
Stacking ETFs that hold the same securities.
A world ETF and a US ETF overlap heavily. You think you are diversifying, you are doubling an exposure.
Switching funds after every bad year.
Each switch can trigger tax and fees, and you often buy after the rise.
Believing a famous manager guarantees a result.
A past record cannot be projected forward. Persistence of outperformance is weak in the studies.
Taking "enhanced index" for "index".
The fund is active, with a contained but intended tracking error. Its fees are those of an active fund.
Not reading the KID.
It runs to a few pages and gives fees, risk, recommended holding period and scenarios. It is the most useful document before buying.
Seeing a forecast in a simulator.
A simulator applies your assumptions. It knows nothing about the future: change them and look at the gap.
Combining active and passive
Combining is not a lukewarm compromise. It is a way of separating two questions: which base exposure do you want, and where do you accept paying more to try to do better. Three rules help avoid mistakes.
- Cap the active share before buying, not after. A share decided in advance holds up better when the market changes.
- Avoid duplicates. An active satellite on world equities, on top of a passive world core, partly cancels the point of one of the two.
- Keep track of the extra cost. Note the satellite's TER, compare it every year with the passive equivalent and with relative performance. If the gap has been negative for three to five years, the satellite's reason for being should be re-examined.
An active satellite on bonds, where the index is less efficient, or on a precise theme does not overlap with a world equity core. That combination raises fewer duplication problems than the reverse.
Twelve charts to see the mechanisms
Each chart comes with its data table and its assumptions. Ten are simulations with stated assumptions, one is an arithmetic calculation, one reproduces fees taken from issuer factsheets. No historical performance series is plotted: we could not re-read fund performance at the source over a common period. Colours do not qualify a strategy: none is "good" or "bad" on screen.
Chart 1. Capital by annual fees, up to 30 years
€10,000 invested once, constant gross return of 7% a year, fees of 0%, 0.2% or 1.2% a year taken from the value. No contributions or tax.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Duration | No fees | Passive at 0.2% | Active at 1.2% |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0 years | €10,000 | €10,000 | €10,000 |
| 5 years | €14,026 | €13,895 | €13,256 |
| 10 years | €19,672 | €19,307 | €17,573 |
| 15 years | €27,590 | €26,827 | €23,296 |
| 20 years | €38,697 | €37,276 | €30,883 |
| 25 years | €54,274 | €51,794 | €40,939 |
| 30 years | €76,123 | €71,968 | €54,271 |
Chart 2. Cumulative outperformance over 20 years that the active fund must earn to match the passive fund
Gross market return 7% a year, duration 20 years, passive at 0.2%. Each bar corresponds to an annual fee gap between active and passive.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Annual fee gap | Cumulative outperformance required |
|---|---|
| 0.05 pt | 0.9% |
| 0.25 pt | 4.8% |
| 0.50 pt | 9.8% |
| 1.00 pt | 20.4% |
| 1.50 pt | 32.1% |
| 2.00 pt | 44.8% |
Chart 3. Capital after 30 years by level of annual fees
€10,000 invested once, gross return of 7% a year, duration 30 years, no contributions or tax.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Annual fees | Final capital |
|---|---|
| 0.1% | €74,017 |
| 0.2% | €71,968 |
| 0.5% | €66,144 |
| 1.0% | €57,435 |
| 1.5% | €49,840 |
| 2.0% | €43,219 |
Chart 4. Three scenarios: the active fund does better, the same, or worse than the market before fees
€10,000 over 20 years, market at 7% gross, passive at 0.2% fees, active at 1.2%. The manager's gross gap is assumed constant: +2, 0 or −2 points a year.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Scenario | Passive at 0.2% | Active at 1.2% |
|---|---|---|
| Active above (+2 pts) | €37,276 | €44,913 |
| Active similar (0 pt) | €37,276 | €30,883 |
| Active below (−2 pts) | €37,276 | €21,084 |
Chart 5. Regular contributions: what comes from your payments, what comes from gains
€200 paid every month, constant gross return of 5% a year, fees of 0.2%, zero starting capital, no tax.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Duration | Cumulative contributions | Gains |
|---|---|---|
| 5 years | €12,000 | €1,497 |
| 10 years | €24,000 | €6,559 |
| 20 years | €48,000 | €31,396 |
| 30 years | €72,000 | €85,445 |
Chart 6. Four typical markets: value of a passive ETF at 0.2%
Base 100 at the start. Annual returns alternate around a mean: bull 9% ± 5, bear −4% ± 6, volatile 5% ± 18, sideways 1% ± 4. Fees 0.2%. Returns are set by construction, not observed.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Year | Bull market | Bear market | Volatile market | Sideways market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 |
| Year 2 | 118.1 | 91.4 | 106.6 | 101.4 |
| Year 4 | 139.5 | 83.6 | 113.6 | 102.9 |
| Year 6 | 164.8 | 76.4 | 121.1 | 104.4 |
| Year 8 | 194.7 | 69.8 | 129.1 | 105.9 |
| Year 10 | 230.0 | 63.8 | 137.6 | 107.4 |
Chart 7. Range of possible outcomes of a 60% equity, 40% bond portfolio
2,000 reproducible random draws. Equities: average return 7%, volatility 16%. Bonds: 3% and 6%. Correlation 0.2. Fees 0.2%. €10,000 at the start, €2,400 paid in each year. Annual rebalancing, no tax.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Year | 10th percentile | Median | 90th percentile |
|---|---|---|---|
| Year 0 | €10,000 | €10,000 | €10,000 |
| Year 5 | €21,271 | €26,528 | €34,050 |
| Year 10 | €35,343 | €47,181 | €64,700 |
| Year 15 | €52,483 | €74,122 | €107,617 |
| Year 20 | €72,090 | €107,324 | €160,879 |
Chart 8. Currency effect on an investment in a foreign currency
€10,000 converted into a foreign currency, assets up 8%, foreign currency down 5% against the euro, conversion fees of 0.25% at entry and at exit.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Item | Effect on capital |
|---|---|
| Entry fees | −€25 |
| Effect of the assets | +€798 |
| Effect of currency | −€539 |
| Exit fees | −€26 |
| Net result | +€209 |
Chart 9. Total cost of an investment over 20 years by number of orders
€2,400 paid in each year for 20 years, gross return of 6%, TER of 0.2%, brokerage of €1 per order, bid-ask spread of 0.10% (0.05% on purchase, 0.05% on sale), no currency conversion or custody fees, final sale included.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Order frequency | TER | Brokerage | Bid-ask spread |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rare purchases (1 order a year) | €1,496 | €21 | €70 |
| Monthly purchases (12 a year) | €1,489 | €241 | €69 |
| Frequent purchases (52 a year) | €1,464 | €1,041 | €69 |
Chart 10. Annual fees recorded on the factsheets of six funds
Ongoing charges (TER) as shown on the issuer factsheets consulted on 17 November 2026: iShares October 2026, Vanguard 31 October 2026, Amundi 31 July 2026 (management fees and other costs), JPMorgan 31 August 2026 according to the factsheets.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Fund | Annual fees |
|---|---|
| iShares World (passive) | 0.20% |
| Vanguard All-World (passive) | 0.14% |
| Amundi Europe (passive) | 0.12% |
| JPM World (active) | 0.25% |
| JPM Europe (active) | 0.25% |
| JPM All Country (active) | 0.25% |
Chart 11. Share of gross return absorbed by fees, by level of return
Fees of 0.2% or 1.2% a year set against an annual gross return of 2, 3, 5, 7 or 10%. Simple arithmetic: fees divided by gross return.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Annual gross return | Fees of 0.2% | Fees of 1.2% |
|---|---|---|
| 2% gross | 10% | 60% |
| 3% gross | 7% | 40% |
| 5% gross | 4% | 24% |
| 7% gross | 3% | 17% |
| 10% gross | 2% | 12% |
Chart 12. Three illustrative paths over five years: index, passive ETF, active ETF
Series generated by the calculation module (seed 7, chosen for readability): market at 7% a year and 15% volatility, passive at 0.2%, active at 1.2% with 1 extra point of gross return and 3 points of specific risk. Base 100.
The chart needs JavaScript. The values are in the data table below.
Chart data
| Month | Index | Passive ETF | Active ETF |
|---|---|---|---|
| Month 0 | 100.0 | 100.0 | 100.0 |
| Month 12 | 105.5 | 105.7 | 107.3 |
| Month 24 | 109.1 | 109.2 | 108.4 |
| Month 36 | 123.0 | 123.1 | 121.0 |
| Month 48 | 141.8 | 141.5 | 136.0 |
| Month 60 | 110.1 | 110.0 | 105.2 |
Seven simulators to run the numbers yourself
The seven tools below apply your assumptions, nothing more. They are educational simulations: no result is a forecast, a guaranteed return or advice. Each one shows its assumptions, flags impossible values and resets in one click. None includes tax, except the last one, as an option. The calculations run in your browser: nothing is sent.
The simulators need JavaScript. Without it, use the tables in this guide: they give the results of typical cases.
Simulator 1. ETF fee calculator
Same gross return, two fee levels: what is left at the end of the period?
- Constant gross return, fees taken continuously from the value.
- Annual net return = gross return − fees; monthly contributions at the end of the month.
- No tax, inflation, spread or brokerage.
Simulator 2. Gross outperformance needed to match a passive ETF
How much must the manager add each year, before fees, to reach the same capital?
- Gross outperformance assumed constant every year.
- The threshold is the annual cost gap (ongoing charges and extra costs) between the active and the passive fund.
- Reaching the threshold only catches up with the passive fund, it does not beat it.
Simulator 3. Regular investing
Periodic contributions over 5, 10, 20 or 30 years: share of contributions and share of gains.
- Constant gross return: reality is irregular, and the order of good and bad years matters for someone who contributes regularly.
- The amount contributed per year is the same whatever frequency you choose.
- No tax or order fees.
Simulator 4. Market scenarios
Bullish, bearish, volatile or sideways: parameters are visible and editable.
- Annual returns alternate around a mean: a high year, a low year. It is a textbook model, not a market.
- The active fund's gross gap is constant and chosen by you: leaving it at zero shows the effect of fees alone.
- Maximum drawdown is measured on year-end values.
Simulator 5. Risk and range of possible outcomes
2,000 random draws of an equity and bond portfolio: a range, not a forecast.
- Log-normal annual returns, independent from one year to the next, with a constant correlation between equities and bonds.
- The model underestimates crashes: real markets have fatter tails and periods when everything falls together.
- The parameters are yours, not estimated from data. A different set of parameters gives a different range.
- Reproducible draw: the same parameters give the same result.
Simulator 6. Currency effect
An investment in a foreign currency: what comes from the assets, what comes from the currency, what fees take.
- A single period: you convert, invest, sell and convert back.
- Currency applies to the share exposed to the foreign currency. A currency-hedged ETF reduces this share.
- Conversion fees apply at entry and at exit, on the value at that moment.
Simulator 7. Total cost of an investment
TER, brokerage, bid-ask spread, currency, custody fees: all in a single figure.
- The TER is counted once, as a reduction of the return: it is already inside the value of the fund.
- Brokerage and spread are paid on every purchase and on the final sale. The spread entered is the total gap, half is paid on each crossing.
- Tax, if you enter one, is a simple rate on the final gain, isolated from the rest: it is not your tax situation. Check your wrapper in the tax guide.
Conclusion and twelve-point checklist
An active ETF and a passive ETF answer two different questions. The passive one asks: which market do I want to hold, at the lowest cost? The active one asks: how much am I ready to pay to try to move away from it, and for how long? No public study gives the answer for you. Fees, on the other hand, can be calculated, and they are the only certain data in the file.
- I know what I hold. I can say in one sentence which market or strategy my ETF represents.
- I have read the KID. Ongoing charges, transaction costs, recommended holding period, scenarios.
- I know the reference index and whether the fund tracks it or moves away from it.
- I have compared like with like: same region, same currency, same treatment of income.
- I have put a number on the extra cost of an active fund against a passive one, with the second simulator.
- I have added the buying costs: spread, brokerage, currency conversion, custody fees.
- I have looked at the size and age of the fund, to judge the closure risk.
- I have checked the currency of the index, the share class and the listing.
- I do not judge on one year. I look at several years and a full cycle.
- I have decided the active share in advance if I combine the two.
- I know my tax wrapper and its effect on accumulation or distribution.
- I know what I will do if the fund falls by 30%. The answer is prepared before the fall.
To go further: the platform comparison to buy ETFs, the French tax guide, the definition of financial instruments and the site methodology.
Method and what remains unverified
This guide was written from issuer documents read on 17 November 2026 and from a reading of the methods of the reference studies. The list below says what that implies and what we could not establish.
- Fund sheets. The ISINs, fees, indices, domiciles and currencies in table 8 come from the issuer factsheets and documents cited in the sources. For the three JPMorgan funds, the date shown in the document (31 August 2026) could not be matched against the issuer's page currently in force: re-read before any decision.
- Not recorded. The ISIN of the JPM All Country Research Enhanced Index Equity Active, the replication method and currency of the Amundi Core MSCI Europe, and the past performance of every fund.
- Performance studies. The exact percentages of active funds that beat their index (SPIVA Europe, Morningstar Active/Passive Barometer) and the figures of the ESMA report on costs and performance are not reproduced: they could not be read in full for this guide. A one-point gap existed between two readings of the same Morningstar figure (28.4% in the document, 29.4% in a search extract), which confirms the need to go to the source.
- Active ETF market in Europe. Number of funds and assets under management for the category: not verified.
- Tax. The PEA, life insurance and other wrappers are not detailed. No tax reviewer is named on this page.
- Simulators. The calculations were tested by 28 automated checks (zero or identical fees, zero or negative return, durations from one year to forty, no contributions, currency up and down, reproducibility of the draws). These tests verify the arithmetic, not the relevance of the assumptions you enter.
Frequently asked questions (FAQ)
What is the difference between an active ETF and a passive ETF?
A passive ETF tracks an index and copies its composition. An active ETF has a manager who chooses the securities, within the framework of its prospectus, to try to do better than an index or to move away from it. Both are listed funds and fall under the same UCITS regulation.
Does an active ETF always beat the market?
No. Nothing guarantees it. It first has to recover its fees, which are generally higher, before it can beat its index. Its performance can be above or below that of the market, and it varies from one period to another.
Is a passive ETF risk-free?
No. It follows its index up and down. A world equity ETF loses value when equities fall, and being passive does not cushion that. It also keeps currency risk, concentration risk and, depending on the replication, counterparty risk.
What does TER mean?
TER stands for total expense ratio, also called ongoing charges. It is the annual percentage taken from the value of the fund to run it. It appears on no invoice: it is already deducted from the value of the share.
Is the TER enough to compare two ETFs?
No. The cost of buying comes on top: bid-ask spread, brokerage, currency conversion, custody fees. For a passive ETF, the tracking difference also measures what the fund lost against its index.
What is tracking difference?
It is the performance gap between an ETF and its index over a period. For a good passive ETF, it is close to the TER. It differs from tracking error, which measures the variability of that gap.
What is tracking error?
It is the variability of the performance gap between a fund and its index, as an annual percentage. It measures how regular the tracking is. For an active ETF, a high tracking error means the manager moves far from the index.
What is an "enhanced index" active ETF?
It is an active ETF that stays close to its index with small overweights and underweights chosen by the manager. The three JPMorgan funds noted in this guide describe themselves that way. Their gap with the index is deliberately contained, but it exists.
What is the difference between an active ETF and a traditional active fund?
The first is listed on an exchange, is bought like a share and shows a continuous price, with a bid-ask spread. The second is subscribed at the net asset value of the day, often through a bank or a life insurance contract, sometimes with entry fees. Performance studies mostly concern the second.
Why does an active fund cost more?
It pays for a management and research team, and its portfolio turnover generates transaction costs. A passive ETF applies an index rule, which takes fewer resources.
How much must an active ETF beat the market to equal a passive ETF?
By as much as the fee gap between the two. An active fund at 1.2% against a passive fund at 0.2% has to gain about 1 point more a year before fees, consistently. The second simulator calculates this threshold for your fees.
Does one point of fees really matter?
Yes, in the long run. With €10,000 at 7% gross a year, a 1-point fee gap removes about 17% of the final capital after 20 years and about 25% after 30 years. The detail is in table 5.
What is survivorship bias?
Funds that perform badly are often closed or merged and disappear from the rankings. A ranking that keeps only current funds looks better than reality was. Serious studies keep closed funds in their calculations.
Do the studies say that active management always loses?
No. They show that a majority of active funds do not beat their index over the long term in most of the categories studied, but the proportion varies with the category, the period and the region. The exact figures change with each edition: consult the current report.
Do these studies apply to active ETFs?
Not directly. They mostly cover traditional active funds. Active ETFs are a recent category in Europe, with little history and funds that are often small.
What is physical replication?
The fund actually holds the securities of the index, or a representative sample. The iShares Core MSCI World uses a so-called optimised method: it holds a sample, not necessarily every security.
What is synthetic replication?
The fund enters a swap contract with a bank, which pays it the performance of the index. This method adds counterparty risk, which is regulated, and makes it possible to track indices that are hard to access.
What is securities lending?
Some physical ETFs lend securities to intermediaries for a fee. The income reduces the fund's net costs, but adds counterparty risk, which is covered by collateral. Each prospectus sets out the fund's policy.
What is the bid-ask spread?
It is the difference between the price at which you can buy the ETF and the price at which you can sell it on the exchange. It is paid on each crossing and depends on the fund's liquidity and the time of the order. It is small on large funds and wider on small ones.
When should I place an order to limit the spread?
When the underlying markets are open, preferably away from the open and the close, where spreads are often wider. A limit order avoids paying more than planned.
Can an active ETF close?
Yes, like any fund. A small fund is more likely to be closed by its issuer. On liquidation, holders are repaid at the net asset value, but you have to reinvest at a time you did not choose, with the tax consequences of your wrapper.
Does currency matter for an ETF listed in euros?
Yes, if the assets are in foreign currencies. An ETF listed in euros on US equities remains exposed to the dollar. Some funds hedge currency, which reduces this exposure and adds a cost.
Should I choose accumulating or distributing?
It depends on your wrapper and your need for income. An accumulating ETF generates no tax return line as long as it is not sold in a securities account, while a distributing ETF pays taxable income. The choice does not change the fund's gross return.
Is an active ETF riskier?
Not by nature. It adds manager risk: its choices can turn out badly. An enhanced index fund keeps a low tracking error, a concentrated fund has a high one. Look at the announced tracking error and the past maximum drawdown.
How do I check an ETF's fees?
In the KID (key information document) and the issuer's factsheet, which give the ongoing charges and the transaction costs. Be wary of third-party sites, which may show an old figure: the Vanguard FTSE All-World saw its ongoing charges fall in July 2026.
Can I combine an active ETF and a passive ETF?
Yes. A common structure is a broad passive core and capped active satellites. The combination answers a question of cost and risk, it is not better in principle. Decide the active share before buying.
Does regular investing beat investing in one go?
Not systematically. If the market rises on average, investing straight away does better in a majority of cases. Regular contributions reduce the risk of entering just before a fall, not market risk.
What does smart beta do compared with an active ETF?
A smart beta fund tracks an index built on a rule other than capitalisation: equal weighting, low volatility, value. It is passive in the sense of tracking, but its index carries a style bias that can underperform the market for years.
Are bond ETFs judged like equity ETFs?
With more care. Bond markets are more fragmented, replication is often by sampling and tracking errors are wider. Fees also weigh more, because the gross return is lower.
Do the simulators on this page predict my result?
No. They apply your assumptions and nothing else. A constant 7% return does not exist. Change the assumptions and look at the gap rather than the absolute result.
Why does the risk simulator give a range?
Because the future has no single path. The model draws 2,000 random paths from your parameters and shows the values at the tenth percentile, the median and the ninetieth percentile. It underestimates crashes, which real markets do experience.
What tax applies to an ETF in France?
In an ordinary securities account, the gain and the income are taxed at the flat tax (PFU) of 31.4% on 2026 income, or at the progressive scale by option. The PEA and life insurance have their own rules, not detailed here. See the site's tax guide.
Are active ETFs eligible for the PEA?
It depends on the fund and its eligibility, which the issuer states. This point was not verified for this guide: consult the fund's document and the official source before buying.
Where can I buy an ETF?
With a stock broker, in a securities account, a PEA or a life insurance contract depending on the case. Brokerage, currency and custody fees vary widely from one broker to another. The site's platform comparison puts them side by side.
Does this guide recommend an ETF?
No. The six funds in table 8 illustrate the method for reading a factsheet. They are neither recommended nor ranked. Past performance is not shown in this guide and is no guide to future performance.
Sources and legal basis
Issuer documents read (consulted on 17 November 2026)
- iShares: product page of the Core MSCI World UCITS ETF (USD, accumulating) (opens in a new window)Key data: TER 0.20%, domicile Ireland, accumulating, share class launched on 25 September 2009, assets as of 13 November 2026.
- iShares: October 2026 monthly factsheet, Core MSCI World (opens in a new window)"Optimised" methodology, physical structure, 1,250 holdings, 3-year beta of 1.00, MSCI World Net index.
- iShares: KID (KIID) of the Core MSCI World, ISIN IE00B4L5Y983 (opens in a new window)Split of securities lending income: 62.5% to the fund, 37.5% to BlackRock. Version of the document not dated in the extract read.
- Vanguard: monthly factsheet of the FTSE All-World UCITS ETF (USD, accumulating) (opens in a new window)Ongoing charges 0.14%, ISIN IE00BK5BQT80, physical replication, launched on 23 July 2019. Factsheet of 31 October 2026 according to the extract read.
- Vanguard: factsheet with the notice to holders on the reduction of ongoing charges (opens in a new window)Notice of 21 July 2026: reduction of ongoing charges effective on 28 July 2026. Older version showing 0.19%.
- Vanguard: information on fund costs and charges (opens in a new window)FTSE All-World line: ongoing charges 0.14%, transaction costs 0.02%, total 0.16%. Date of the document not read.
- JPMorgan AM: factsheet of the Global Research Enhanced Index Equity Active UCITS ETF (USD, accumulating) (opens in a new window)ISIN IE00BF4G6Y48, TER 0.25%, MSCI World Net index, launched on 10 October 2018. Date shown: 31 August 2026, to be re-read.
- JPMorgan AM: factsheet of the Europe Research Enhanced Index Equity Active UCITS ETF (EUR, accumulating) (opens in a new window)ISIN IE00BF4G7183, TER 0.25%, MSCI Europe Net index. Date shown: 31 August 2026, to be re-read.
- JPMorgan AM: factsheet of the All Country Research Enhanced Index Equity Active UCITS ETF (USD, accumulating) (opens in a new window)TER 0.25%, MSCI ACWI index, domicile Ireland. ISIN not recorded.
- Amundi ETF: monthly factsheet of the Amundi Core MSCI Europe UCITS ETF (opens in a new window)ISIN LU1437015735 (class A), passive management, management fees and other costs 0.12%, Luxembourg-law SICAV, data as of 31 July 2026.
Regulators and studies (general addresses: specific documents not re-read for this guide)
- ESMA: European Securities and Markets Authority (opens in a new window)Q&A on the application of the UCITS directive (mention of active or passive management) and annual report on the costs and performance of retail products. Figures of the 2025 edition not verified.
- S&P Dow Jones Indices: SPIVA (opens in a new window)Method noted: equal weighting of funds, closed funds kept, returns net of fees. Percentages not reproduced.
- Morningstar: Active/Passive Barometer (opens in a new window)Method noted: comparison with a composite of passive funds, net of fees. Percentages not reproduced.
On this site
- Tax on trading and investing in France, 2027 returnFlat tax of 31.4% and declaration of capital gains on ETFs.
- NextFinTech.eu methodologyThe site's rules on sourcing, dating and neutrality.



